Skip Navigation
Phone: 800-275-6401
Text Size: A A A

To schedule an appointment

Providers call:1-800-332-8901
Patients call:1-800-275-6401

This provider sees patients at the following locations:

Orthopaedics Lewisburg
250 Reitz Blvd
Lewisburg, PA 17837
Orthopaedics Montoursville
780 Broad St
Montoursville, PA 17754
Orthopaedics Selinsgrove
620 University Ave
Selinsgrove, PA 17870
Geisinger - Woodbine Lane
115 Woodbine Ln
Danville, PA 17822

There is no publicly available rating for this care provider for one or more of the following reasons:
  1. He or she does not see patients in the outpatient clinic setting.
  2. He or she sees patients, but has not yet received the minimum number of Patient Satisfaction Reviews. To be eligible for display, we require a minimum of 30 surveys. This ensures that the rating is accurate and statistically reliable.
  3. He or she is a community provider, not a Geisinger-employed provider. Community providers tend to see patients in their own private outpatient practices, which we do not survey.

McElroy, Matthew Thomas, DO Visit for information on Matthew Thomas McElroy, DO. Find contact information, medical education, affiliated hospitals and more.
Overall Rating:
4.7 out of 5
1 213 ratings

Practicing Specialties:

  • Family Medicine, Board Certified, 2003
  • Sports Medicine, Board Certified, 2005
  • Orthopaedics


  • Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine 2000


  • Geisinger Medical Center 2003


  • Saint Vincent Health System - Erie, PA 2005
    Sports Medicine

Clinical Interests:

Manual medicine, exercise induced asthma, concussions, high altitude illness, fracture care, musculoskeletal ultrasound, diagnostic and therapeutic, and platelet rich plasma injections for chronic tendonosis, ultrasound guided micro tenotomy for chronic tendon issues

Related Interests:

Mountain biking, downhill and cross country skiing, endurance racing, trail running, kayaking. Dr. McElroy is team physician for Bucknell University and Milton Area High School.


  • German

Professional Memberships:

  • American Academy of Family Practice
  • American Medical Society for Sport Medicine
  • American Osteopathic Society for Sports Medicine

Patient Satisfaction Ratings:

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to care provider-related questions on our nationally recognized Press Ganey Patient Satisfaction Survey. Responses are measured on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the best score. Learn more about our survey >
1. Friendliness/courtesy of provider
- 4.8 out of 5
2. Provider explanations of prob/condition
- 4.7 out of 5
3. Provider concern for questions/worries
- 4.8 out of 5
4. Provider efforts to include in decisions
- 4.7 out of 5
5. Provider information about medications
- 4.6 out of 5
6. Provider instructions for follow-up care
- 4.6 out of 5
7. Provider spoke using clear language
- 4.8 out of 5
8. Time provider spent with patient
- 4.7 out of 5
9. Patients' confidence in provider
- 4.7 out of 5
10. Likelihood of recommending provider
- 4.7 out of 5

Patient Comments:

The comments are submitted by patients (or their caregivers) and reflect their views and opinions. The comments are not endorsed by and do not necessarily reflect the views of Geisinger. Learn more about our survey >
Feb 27
He is an excellent doctor and I hope Geisinger doesn't lose him like they do other good doctors.
Feb 27
This is the 2nd time that Dr McElroy has taken care of the pain in my knees d/t a torn meniscus. I think he is a great doctor and I am thankful to be able to get relief from the pain with his help.
Feb 24
The staff were all very nice and explained everything well. We were only in the office for 15 minutes and the distance that we had to drive to arrive at the facility was about an hour. I don't think that the visit was worth the drive. Dr. McElroy was really nice, but he didn't tell us any more information than the PA in the Lock Haven Office.
Feb 24
The Dr. told me the the surgeon's office would call for follow-up care, but after two weeks, still no call. That is not THIS doctor's fault.
Feb 21
Took his time. Great Doctor
Feb 17
Dr. McElroy and staff are always very professional and explain everything to you before doing exam/procedure.
Feb 3
Dr McElroy was professional yet very approachable. He addressed my injury and concerns as an athlete, not just another patient. As a cross country coach; I'm looking forward to working together to get back to running ASAP.
Feb 2
Dr. McElroy is a wonderful doctor. I have been going to him for years, and he is always courteous, kind and efficient. And I hardly ever get a bruise spot when he gives me a shot or extract fluid from my rotator cuff.
Jan 30
Dr. McElroy is terrific -- listens, explains, is concerned. I also greatly appreciate his team of health professionals. They work well with him and with each other. It's clear they enjoy working with him and they respect his work.
Jan 19
There was also an intern ( not sure of his title) working with dr. and he was also very nice & personable
Jan 16
No meds prescribed.
Jan 11
Dr. M and his staff were really good to work with. I was coming for a second opinion, and was very glad that Dr. M was recommended to me.
Jan 9
very good
Dec 22, 2016
I informed the office I'd need more on final visit he spent maybe 1 1/2 minutes with me, declared he couldn't help me and neither could ortho. surgeon and told me to find another dr. I asked for meds until reestablished and was told because he had given a total of 60 in previous months it would be flagged.Provider initially was very friendly and seemed to care about my pain and medical issues. I followed the instructions implicitly but had to reschedule one appointment due to vehicle breakdown. I wasn't yet out of meds but would be before I could be seen.
Dec 7, 2016
dr provided me with several treatment options to consider for future planning. he gave me information to read about as welll
Dec 2, 2016
Dr McElroy is Excellent!!1
Nov 28, 2016
Dr. McElroy is amazing her has treated Maddie before and remembered her visit from 2 years ago. It means a lot when a very busy provider can remember patients. This is the kind of care that instills trust and respect
Nov 16, 2016
I have great faith in his diagnosis and value the advice he gives me.
Nov 16, 2016
McElroy is a great caring doctor. soooo thankful for him!
Nov 4, 2016
Very kind, compassionate & caring physician.
Oct 14, 2016
Dr. McElroy is the best. He listens to and addresses all my concerns. I feel very comfortable asking him questions. He never makes me feel like I am putting him out. He is an excellent doctor and I am so thankful that he is my doctor.
Sep 26, 2016
First time being seen by Dr McElroy. Would highly recommend him. Great physician who gave wonderful care.
Sep 21, 2016
I did already recommend him to someone in the area.
Sep 8, 2016
I have recommended Dr. McElroy to others - All the clinical staff there are excellent!!
Sep 8, 2016
Dr McElroy is excellent and I have already recommended him to others. He is a great asset to the Geisinger System.
Aug 25, 2016
Dr. McElroy is Excellent!!!!
Aug 24, 2016
Aug 5, 2016
Dr. McElroy was easy to talk with b/c he really listened & was empathetic. I didn't feel rushed or patronized in anyway. I felt confident in his ability to help me.
Aug 5, 2016
Excellent. Doctor is an excellent listener and very patient. Listens to all concerns - never dismissive. Discusses problems and proposes follow up activities and care. Good on...
Aug 3, 2016
I had the wors experience ever with the dr it seems like he doesn,t care about his paients I have heard his by a couple of people too... I will never recommend him to anyone I know he will be the last person I would send anyone too... He is very rude...
Aug 1, 2016
Dr. McElroy is great!
Jul 28, 2016
Dr. McElroy and his staff provided an excellent experience during my injection. Prior to my injection Dr. McElroy spent time with me and my family discussing the different injection options available to me, making sure that I was comfortable with my informed decision prior to him performing the injection. I found this to be very reassuring and thoughtful of Dr. McElroy. He took the time to answer any and all questions that myself and my family member had regarding the injection prior to and during the procedure. I would highly recommend Dr. McElroy and his staff, he is an excellent health care provider that cares about the health and well-being of his patients.
Jul 26, 2016
Dr. Mceroy has always been very kind and respectful. he listens to how I feel and what my goals are and suggests the best medical treatment. very positive experiences.
Jul 19, 2016
Dr. McElroy is one of the best ortho MD's I have experienced at Geisinger. He is professional caring & knowledgeable.
June 29, 2016
Need more doctors like this--Always friendly and caring. A real person!!
June 27, 2016
I have tremendous respect for Dr. McElroy and will miss his expertise, as I am moving out of state. I hope to find comparable expert Ortho care in San Antonio.
June 21, 2016
Had a shot in my knee, 3 days ago and the pain level remained unchanged. Disappointed in that.
June 20, 2016
Excellent and caring physician.
June 13, 2016
I was given excellent and very complete follow-up/aftercare instructions
May 27, 2016
I was happy to have relief from knee pain.
May 26, 2016
All of my visits with Dr. McElroy have been a positive experience. I completely trust him in my care. He is very friendly and I have complete confidence in him. I would highly recommend him to anyone needed Orthopedic care.
May 23, 2016
Dr. McElroy is a very caring and compassionate doctor who tries to help his patients.
May 10, 2016
Dr McElroy inspires confidence in me and makes me feel very cared for
May 5, 2016
Dr. McElroy acted like a prima donna - too good to even examine me! He allowed the PA to do all the work. Very disappointed in this ortho appt.!
May 2, 2016
Dr. McElroy- top notch! He listens and involves me in the decisions regarding my treatment. VERY personable, knowledgeable, he really cares.
Apr 29, 2016
Dr. McElroy is the best care provider. He is always very kind and very caring and does a great job.
Apr 13, 2016
Pain in R knee - physician ordered an X-Ray done during that appt. an MRI was performed 4/26 - the office called the next day with the results I was given an appt. that morning to reserve an injection as we have done in the past - If no relief Dr. suggests see ortho Dr. for discussion. Dr. McElroy gave me an appointment on 4/27 AM even though he had to leave at 11:30 to go to Selengrove.
Apr 7, 2016
Dr. McElroy is WONDERFUL. He is kind, smart, and treats me like an athlete - he understands that I can't just be "okay," I need to be functional enough to train and complete. And he _____ about taking care of me as he would be a college athlete. I appreciate that.
Apr 4, 2016
Was very thorough, explained so I would unstand. Courteous,caring. But knew his job very well.
March 28, 2016
I am extremely satisfied with the Ortho care I have received from Dr. McElroy.