Skip Navigation
Phone: 800-275-6401
Text Size: A A A

To schedule an appointment

Providers call:1.800.332.8901
Patients call:1.800.275.6401

This provider sees patients at the following locations:

Orthopaedics Lewisburg
250 Reitz Blvd
Lewisburg, PA 17837
Orthopaedics Montoursville
780 Broad St
Montoursville, PA 17754
Orthopaedics Selinsgrove
620 University Ave
Selinsgrove, PA 17870
Geisinger - Woodbine Lane
115 Woodbine Ln
Danville, PA 17822

There is no publicly available rating for this care provider for one or more of the following reasons:
  1. He or she does not see patients in the outpatient clinic setting.
  2. He or she sees patients, but has not yet received the minimum number of Patient Satisfaction Reviews. To be eligible for display, we require a minimum of 30 surveys. This ensures that the rating is accurate and statistically reliable.
  3. He or she is a community provider, not a Geisinger-employed provider. Community providers tend to see patients in their own private outpatient practices, which we do not survey.

McElroy, Matthew Thomas, DO Visit for information on Matthew Thomas McElroy, DO. Find contact information, medical education, affiliated hospitals and more.
Overall Rating:
4.7 out of 5
1 246 ratings

Practicing Specialties:

  • Family Medicine, Board Certified, 2003
  • Sports Medicine, Board Certified, 2005
  • Orthopaedics


  • Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine 2000


  • Geisinger Medical Center 2003


  • Saint Vincent Health System - Erie, PA 2005
    Sports Medicine

Clinical Interests:

Manual medicine, exercise induced asthma, concussions, high altitude illness, fracture care, musculoskeletal ultrasound, diagnostic and therapeutic, and platelet rich plasma injections for chronic tendonosis, ultrasound guided micro tenotomy for chronic tendon issues

Related Interests:

Mountain biking, downhill and cross country skiing, endurance racing, trail running, kayaking. Dr. McElroy is team physician for Bucknell University and Milton Area High School.


  • German

Professional Memberships:

  • American Academy of Family Practice
  • American Medical Society for Sport Medicine
  • American Osteopathic Society for Sports Medicine

Patient Satisfaction Ratings:

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to care provider-related questions on our nationally recognized Press Ganey Patient Satisfaction Survey. Responses are measured on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the best score. Learn more about our survey >
1. Friendliness/courtesy of provider
- 4.8 out of 5
2. Provider explanations of prob/condition
- 4.7 out of 5
3. Provider concern for questions/worries
- 4.7 out of 5
4. Provider efforts to include in decisions
- 4.7 out of 5
5. Provider information about medications
- 4.7 out of 5
6. Provider instructions for follow-up care
- 4.6 out of 5
7. Provider spoke using clear language
- 4.7 out of 5
8. Time provider spent with patient
- 4.6 out of 5
9. Patients' confidence in provider
- 4.7 out of 5
10. Likelihood of recommending provider
- 4.7 out of 5

Patient Comments:

The comments are submitted by patients (or their caregivers) and reflect their views and opinions. The comments are not endorsed by and do not necessarily reflect the views of Geisinger. Learn more about our survey >
Apr 29
Dr. McElroy is the best care provider. He is always very kind and very caring and does a great job.
Apr 7
Dr. McElroy is WONDERFUL. He is kind, smart, and treats me like an athlete - he understands that I can't just be "okay," I need to be functional enough to train and complete. And he _____ about taking care of me as he would be a college athlete. I appreciate that.
Apr 4
Was very thorough, explained so I would unstand. Courteous,caring. But knew his job very well.
March 28
I am extremely satisfied with the Ortho care I have received from Dr. McElroy.
March 21
Dr. McElroy was in a hurry or was intimidated that I had done some research and was well educated on my condition. He gave me a very expensive orthotic arch brace and was selling insoles (which I already had). He was very quick and did not explain things well. He seemed upset that I was asking questions and making suggestions for how to improve my pain. I read my notes in my geisinger and he charted things we didn't even talk about. My husband accompanied me to this appointment and he was equally disgusted by this appointment.
March 21
I get tired of being a test subject for observation by students. Had 2 students in room, which is small room.
March 18
Could not have asked for a better doctor! Thorough, kind, and competent.
March 11
Dr McElroy is a superb clinician.
March 7
Excellent service from Dr. M. McElroy & his assistants!
March 4
doctor was to busy going over mri with the medical student in the room. medicare will be notified of this and got see see a different doctor who know what their doing and not worried about teaching.
Feb 23
Dr. McElroy listens to my concerns and getting this medical treatment enables me to continue to do the activities I enjoy.
Feb 4
What a nice guy!
Feb 1
The doctor, students, technicians all worked very well together in determining the care needed and describing it in terms my child understood and allowing time for questions. We will definitely recommend this office/clinic to anyone who we cross paths with requiring this specialty of care.
Jan 26
Med student that was with Dr should not be eating as walking in go exam room
Jan 25
Dr. McElroy is fantastic! Very professional, knowledgable and efficient. Give him a raise!
Jan 18
Everyone I came in contact with in orthopaedics were friendly and caring and I felt at ease with all of them
Jan 18
Incredibly smart, friendly doctor. he knew his stuff. Quite handsome too!
Jan 7
Approval of the procedure was gotten from the scheduled doctor and then performed by an intern with another intern observing. Intern did a great job.
Jan 6
I would highly recommend him. He was very nice and friendly.
Dec 29, 2015
One of the reasons why I enjoy Dr. McElroy so much is that I can use medical terminology with him and he isn't condescending at all. He respects my intelligence.
Dec 21, 2015
Nov 27, 2015
Dr. McElroy is one of the nicest people I know and very caring.
Nov 2, 2015
Not the physician's fault, something failed in the process leading to get into the exam room. As a Geisinger employee, this Patient Experience was very disheartening. I placed a message on My Geisinger and no one ever got back to me.
Oct 30, 2015
great visit
Oct 28, 2015
I had additional questions & he was very helpful & had unrelated issue which he explained & gave me exercise handouts.
Oct 26, 2015
Dr. McElroy is excellent. Very knowledgeable, caring, and "goes the extra mile" in his medical care. Very reassuring & really listens to my concerns.
Oct 26, 2015
Great doctor!!!
Oct 12, 2015
Every body was friendly & professional.
Sep 17, 2015
Always. Good
Sep 10, 2015
I really like Dr McElroy's ability to focus on me. It's obvious that he's busy and has an amazingly full schedule, yet he doesn't rush me, doesn't seem impatient. Takes the time to fully answer my questions and seems fully focused on me.
Sep 2, 2015
I waited in the examining room for at least 25 minutes, with no word as to why Dr. McE. was late. He finally came breezing in and offered no apology or explanation for his tardiness. His attitude was all business, no wasted words; his demeanor was not especially friendly.
Aug 28, 2015
Dr McElroys assistant is a very pleasent person and a joy to talk to. (Can't remember his name though).
Aug 24, 2015
As already described on a previous comment, I feel as though I wasted my time and money for the care provider to tell me to stretch.
Aug 20, 2015
Very pleased with physician.
Aug 19, 2015
It's frustrating to take the time to come to an appointment, spend all of 5 minutes with the doctor and then cough up a $30 copay, particularly given that this is the third time I've done so for this issue and it seems as though at least one of those visits could have been a simple phone call.
Aug 6, 2015
Dr. McElroy needs no recommendations, appointments with him are highly prized. He knows I graduated pre-med, so he gives me the full detail of what he sees, and includes me in the discussion about treatment. He and his staff are off the charts excellent. What they can do with an ultrasound in the office is amazing. What they can detect is stunning! They are outstanding in orthopedics, the best!
Aug 5, 2015
Dr McElroy and Brian were superb with the treatment/injections I received. Dr McElroy is the best!!!
Jul 31, 2015
Dr. McElroy was very professional and thorough. I was impressed with his compentency.
Jul 30, 2015
Physician went immediately to knee replacement option instead of explaining why this would be best option
Jul 27, 2015
After we asked for a consult with an ortho resident our Doctor dismissed our concerns and did not see us the rest of our time in the ED. Nursing Team Coordinator is the person who did our discharge.
Jul 7, 2015
I am always very happy with Dr. McElroy
June 22, 2015
Dr. Mcelroy is a great doctor I would recommend him to anyone. I am grateful & see him on a regular basis.
June 10, 2015
Excellent experience.
June 8, 2015
No need for medication or return at this time. I was please with my appt and the recommendations.
June 5, 2015
I really like Dr. McElroy's demeanor - he's professional, approachable, concerned. I feel very comfortable with him - I trust him.